Weekly Member Update - July 27, 2026

Image Courtesy of the Facebook Page of Troy Mayor Carmella Mantello

The Week in Flock

  • The big Flocking local news this week was the felling of three Flock cameras on the streets of Troy overnight Thursday. In her trademark hyperbolic style, Troy Mayor Carmella Mantello called the vandalism “violent and unhinged,” but it’s hard to not lay some of the blame for this circumstance at the feet of Mantello and her administration. Remember, these cameras were installed — as they often are — without the knowledge and input of the Collar City community and, when Mantello’s constituents started voicing their vociferous objections earlier this year, Mantello dismissed them out of hand. And then, when the Troy City Council tried to shut the cameras down, Mantello took the extraordinary and ridiculous step of declaring a citywide state of emergency to keep the Flock funds flowing. So, for months now, the will of the Trojan People has been stymied; is it any wonder that someone got sick of looking at these tools of mass surveillance and resorted to self help? As our friends with DeFlock Troy plainly stated, “Some people feel like they need to take matters into their own hands when their government is not . . . it’s unfortunate.” Perhaps there’s light on the horizon, however; the Troy City Council took steps toward limiting Mantello’s emergency powers last week and, this coming week, Mantello’s response is due to the City Council’s lawsuit seeking to vacate the still-in-effect, now-118-day state of emergency. Meanwhile, the felled cameras will invariably be replaced; while the cameras remain Flock’s property, thanks to the language of Flock’s Terms and Conditions, the taxpayers of the City of Troy will unfortunately be responsible for the cost of replacement.

  • For what it’s worth, it isn’t just the citizens of Troy that are taking the scourge of Flock surveillance into their own frustrated hands. Similar incidents have been reported in Ashland, Ohio, Houston, Texas, Athens, Georgia, New Bern, North Carolina and in Franklin County, Pennsylvania, where the rascals replaced the cameras with American flags. Nice touch.

  • And the stories of police misuse of Flock surveillance continue to roll in. This week, it was a detective in Orlando, Florida who used Flock to track her husband’s ex-wife.

  • Even when citizens are successful in getting rid of Flock, local electeds will often miss the point and just swap out Flock for another surveillance company. So goes the story for our friends in Syracuse; out with Flock, in with Axon

  • One assurance you will always hear from your beneficent local law enforcement agency is that they do not share their Flock data with ICE. That’s nice, but it doesn’t matter. Because of the interconnected nature of Flock’s vast network, you only need one collaborative police agency somewhere to open the door to ICE, and then ICE can see everywhere. The Minnesota Star Tribune is the latest to prove this point; during ICE’s murderous Operation Metro Surge in Minneapolis last winter, ICE didn't need cooperation from the Minneapolis Police Department, they could get access to Flock data in Minneapolis from their friends in Indiana, North Carolina or the US Postal Service. The problem is the cameras, pure and simple, and that problem can’t be cured by your well-meaning local cops. Remember this when the Troy PD speaks in platitudes and agrees to “common-sense guidelines” over the use of Flock cameras; so long as the Rensselaer County Sheriff keeps cooperating with ICE, any restrictions on the Troy PD aren’t worth the Local Law #3 that they will be printed on. And, even if AG Tish James gets her way and forces Sheriff Bourgault to stop working with ICE, so long as Troy — and Albany, and Green Island, and East Greenbush, and so on — has Flock surveillance cameras on its streets, ICE is looking in through a back door afforded to them by some other cops states away.

  • August 16 - 22 is the National Week of Action Against ALPRs; here’s the local agenda.

Odds & Ends:

Next
Next

Weekly Member Update - July 20, 2026