Weekly Member Update - November 16, 2026

One of these things is not like the others: Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer greets the incoming class of freshmen Democratic US Senators; Scott Colom (MI) & Mary Peltola (AK), not pictured

The schadenfreude has abated. The triumphant thrill has turned to quiet satisfaction and is well on its way toward the mean of cautious anxiety. In the wake of the Great Bluenami of 2026, we’re starting to see the data crunching and postgame analysis and, wouldn’t you know it, there is a push to create the narrative that moderation and centrism were the keys to Democratic victories, as if Democrats prevailed in spite of their progressive wing, not because of it. Within 36 hours of the polls closing, the Centrist think tank Third Way had already breathlessly declared that “Center-Left Democrats Overperformed and Delivered the Majority.” Convinced that Democratic gains in 2026 were but a mirage, some Democratic strategists are advocating that Democrats need to embrace “heterodox” policy positions — pro-corporal punishment for children, anyone? — as a way to truly succeed in 2028 and beyond.

It’s all bullshit, of course. Yes, there is considerable data suggesting that the Bluenami was the largely the product of Republicans staying home as much as it was Democrats turning out. And, we also know that the Bluenami could have even been bigger, but for Republican redistricting efforts in the lead up to the midterms. But it is also incontrovertible that overwhelmingly Democratic Black turnout throughout the South exceeded its turnout for Kamala Harris in 2024 and proved dispositive in the Mississippi Senate race, suggesting what Tessie McMillan Cottom has called “more trouble ahead for the G.O.P., should the Democrats find the wherewithal to invest in durable, progressive firewalls.” Also, young voters turned out in historic numbers, shifted decidedly Democratic and overwhelmingly expressed a desire for either “substantial change” in how the country is run or a “complete and total upheaval.”

If mobilizing Democratic turnout was the key to the Bluenami, some are crediting the work of activist groups over the past two years for keeping people engaged and demonstrating resistance when MAGA seemed ascendant and the Democratic establishment cowered in paralysis. Rhetorically, successful Democratic candidates across the spectrum adopted not “right vs left,” but “top vs bottom” economic populism as they modeled Zohran Mamdani’s messaging on affordability. And, it was the other side of the cost-of-living coin, corruption, which rose to be the biggest motivating issue for midterm voters; voters were repulsed by the GOP’s open culture of corruption, even as they expressed skepticism about the Democratic Party’s ability to fix it.

The bottom line is that the Bluenami gave us a lot of reassurance that all is not lost, but it also signaled that the battle is not yet won. If the Democratic Party fails to capitalize on this momentum, and quickly, it is readily conceivable that the pendulum swings right again. As Ben Rhodes wrote late last week, “Democratic power in the waning days of the Trump era must look, feel and be different from past incarnations. Governance must be visible, participatory and consequential. If it isn’t, the blue tsunami will recede.”

Senator Bernie Sanders could not have said it more plainly, “The election for Democratic Senate leader will determine whether we continue to tinker around the edges and maintain status quo policies, or whether we finally have the courage to take on enormously powerful special interests and address the unprecedented crises that we face.” The reasons why Chuck Schumer is not the leader this moment demands are myriad. His political instincts are terrible; he still hasn’t endorsed Zohran Mamdani for Mayor, but voted to confirm Sean “Road Rules” Duffy as Transportation Secretary and supported Haley Stevens over Abdul El-Sayed. He’s timid to use power at crucial moments. His ties to AIPAC and the crypto industry are disqualifying. He’s been in Congress for nearly a half-century and has an approval rating of 13%. Unlike his opponent for Majority Leader, Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen, Schumer isn’t committed to the idea of ending the filibuster, even though the filibuster is contrary to the Framers’ constitutional design, disproportionately impedes Democratic priorities over those of their Republican counterparts and “undermines public confidence in democracy and supports the reactionary view that government is good for nothing.” John Fetterman supports Chuck Schumer. We could go on and on.

But Chuck Schumer is not inevitable, despite what he and his supporters are suggesting, and he seems to know it. Rumors are swirling that Schumer is trying to move the Majority Leader election up a week, confirming that the longer the leadership fight goes on, the worse it is for Schumer. So, Kirsten Gillibrand can scold and gaslight us all she wants, Van Hollen’s fulsome campaign is gaining momentum, and we’re here for it.

The Week in Flock

  • Three Assembly Committees held a joint hearing this past week on the need for statewide regulation of ALPRs. The Times Union, News10 and The Gothamist all have reporting, and CBS6 had a sit-down interview about the hearing with local Assembly Member John McDonald, who some say is angling to be Assembly Majority leader come January. In our view, mere regulation — i.e., limits on data retention and sharing, stricter guardrails around police abuse of the technology — while welcome, are, at the end of the day, insufficient. The regulation being contemplated by the Assembly — including the bill carried last session by Syracuse Assembly Member Pamela Hunter which provided the framework for the recently enacted Local Law #3 in Troy — miss two highly salient points. First, we believe that the widespread and indiscriminate data collection being conducted by Flock and other ALPR networks, no matter how regulated, is unconstitutional, and courts are increasingly coming around to that idea. Second, these regulatory schemes generally assume the continued presence of nongovernmental contractors — like Flock surveillance — as the administrators of the ALPR networks being regulated. To our way of thinking, regulating the scope and duration of data retention by local law enforcement is all well and good, but it’s a bit hollow when the data is stored in the servers of billion-dollar corporations who hold a perpetual and irrevocable license to use the data as they see fit. In sum, Flocks and other ALPR networks pose myriad problems, from law-enforcement abuse to corporate data hoarding, and we’re concerned that the regulatory schemes being discussed only address discrete portions of the overarching problem.

  • As if to prove our point, police are not only accessing ALPR data without first establishing probable cause to do so, cops are also increasingly using ALPR data to investigate people because of their “suspicious” driving patterns. So, instead of using an ALPR to help solve crimes under investigation, cops are instead using them to determine whether random people should be investigated for committing crimes they don’t know about. Think about it for a second; you’re driving along, minding your own business, and a cop randomly runs your plate through the ALPR network, looks at where you’ve been and when, and then decides to pull you over, not because you committed a traffic infraction or have been linked to some other known criminal activity, but because the cop in question thinks your driving pattern is weird. If that sounds unconstitutional to you, it’s because it is.

  • Maybe the courts will save us? There is a nascent class action lawsuit underway in Westchester County challenging the legality of the WCPD’s self-contained ALPR system under the New York State Constitution’s prohibition against unlawful searches.

  • Speaking of litigation, as we mentioned back on October 29, Flock is trying to extricate itself from lawsuit looking to invalidate Troy Mayor Carmella Mantello’s ongoing state of emergency which keeps funding for Trojan Flocks flowing.

  • The Times Union has additional reporting on how state grant funding has assisted in the proliferation of Flocks and other ALPRs in our communities.

  • The TU should be applauded for the scope and regularity of its ALPR-related reporting, and here’s another example; a deep-dive 101 on ALPRs and the issues surrounding them by Sarah Trafton.

  • In a dramatic and unexpected turn of events apparently prompted by Columbia County Sheriff Jackie Salvatore, the Columbia County Board of Supervisors unanimously enacted a 90-day moratorium on the use of Flock cameras in the idyllic County, indicating that the cameras will be hooded if Flock doesn’t turn them off first (Flock won’t do that, ask Ithaca). Make no mistake, this is the direct result of grassroots efforts by groups like DeFlock Columbia County. Their efforts brought scrutiny to the largely unnoticed proliferation of cameras in the County; now, County officials are making note of the “troubling” language in the Flock contract and Sheriff Salvatore has questions about how one camera in Kinderhook was replaced by Flock, without her knowledge, after someone cut the camera down over the summer. Without the citizen-led efforts of activists, we’re confident that the Flocks would have continued without scrutiny.

  • East Greenbush might be next to Get the Flock Out. The EG Town Board votes this Wednesday at 6:00 pm. Come join the fun!

Odds & Ends

Next
Next

Weekly Member Update - November 9, 2026